The question on the distinction between $veNATION holders and Passport holders (citizens) has come up often over the past couple of days. There have been very valid concerns that $veNATION holders should be deemed citizens, since they prove their commitment to Nation3 by locking their tokens, and that excluding them from being citizens removed the sense of belonging.
With the current set up, since the number of passports is limited, it might leave a large number of $veNATION holders incapable of participating in tasks and coordinating initiatives in guilds, since at the moment those are limited to Passport holders.
I have been thinking a lot about the topic and I agree that the distinction originally created between the two feels unnatural. The reason we proposed it was to create a limiting factor on the number of citizens in the early days of the project: our concern was that if that number grew before the organization was able to implement clear processes for discussion and governance, it would lead to chaos.
I fully agree that itās important to acknowledge the role of those locking in their $NATION as citizens, both to create the feeling of belonging, and also to include them in governance, internal task-based economy, and services the cloud nation might provide in the future.
Therefore, now that the DAO is progressing towards organizing its governance process and work, Iād like to propose the following internal structure:
-
The first $veNATION holders (with a minimum balance of 2 $veNATION) to claim the 420 Genesis NFT Passports would hold the privileged passport by virtue of their early contribution and larger stake. These passports will be claimable on a first-come, first-serve basis.
-
The Genesis NFT passports would primarily be a form of recognition as Genesis members of what I hope would one day become the worldās most thriving and prosperous nation. In the future, they might also be a requisite for higher-responsibility tasks, since the longer stake represents a higher degree of trust in the ecosystem.
-
Any other $veNATION holders will be able to claim ordinary Citizen NFT Passport. The minimum required balance for this will be discussed in a separate Forum proposal, but Iād suggest something much smaller, eg 0.5 $veNATION.*
-
All of Nation3 ecosystem, including Discord channels, Guilds and their respective Dework tasks, community hangouts, boosted rewards, power to make governance proposals and vote on them, use future cloud nation services, and any other benefits are therefore available to all Citizens.
*Importantly, Iād like to propose a way for this amount to be borrowed from the Nation3 treasury in a private contract to ensure anyone, regardless of their financial status, can join.
An example could look like this:
Anna wants to join Nation3 and contribute as a Citizen, but she doesnāt have the money required to buy enough $NATION for the required lock. She forms an (on-chain) agreement with the DAO to borrow the $veNATION lock required to become a Citizen, so that Anna can start earning by completing tasks in the Nation3 internal economy. Within the next 3 months, the compensation for tasks Anna completes would go towards paying back the lock loan (with no interest) + towards her own lock. After that point, Anna can claim all compensation she makes from completing tasks.
This remains to be evaluated from technical perspective but should be possible.
In this model, the majority of $veNATION holders would also be Citizens (unless they choose not to be), since thereās no additional requirement or cost.
This way, the core executive power, ability to contribute work, as well as all benefits stay with the Citizens. Citizenship also becomes something accessible through a relatively low required stake, and an ability to finance it through a loan if needed.
Look forward to your comments!